'What will be left of the old Birmingham?': Fears over Bull Ring Indoor Market demolition
Concerns rise as the historic Bull Ring Indoor Market in Birmingham is approved for demolition to make way for new flats or student housing, raising questions about the city's heritage preservation.
A leading academic has questioned whether Birmingham is losing too much of its historic identity as plans to demolish the city’s Bull Ring Indoor Market are approved.
Dr Steven McCabe said the move raises deeper questions about the city’s priorities.
“My instant reaction is — do we need more apartments, and will there be anything left of the old Birmingham?” he said.
“I suspect this is part of a greater land grab by developers wanting to have ‘real estate’ ready to take advantage of the arrival of HS2. Whilst I fully acknowledge the importance attached to economic development by politicians, short-term gains tend to ignore the long-term loss of culture and place.”
Dr McCabe warned that the city’s unique character risks being replaced by generic high-rises.
“Birmingham is famous for many things, but I doubt people will marvel at more apartments,” he added.
“I can’t help but make a connection with the recent announcement by Richard Parker that he’d like to see Birmingham become an effective ‘Zone 5’ once HS2 is completed.”
The comments come after Birmingham City Council approved plans for the Bull Ring Indoor Market on Edgbaston Street to be demolished. The site will make way for up to 745 flats, 1,544 student bedrooms, or a blend of both, according to developer Hammerson.
Demolition is expected to begin in late 2027, with construction starting in 2028. Hammerson said it has worked with local stakeholders to extend traders’ leases until that time, with a new permanent market planned for the wider Smithfield redevelopment area.
Harry Badham, chief development and asset repositioning officer at Hammerson, called the decision “a great outcome” that responds to Birmingham’s growing housing needs.
“As long-term backers of Birmingham, we know the potential growth that is achieved with targeted investment and regeneration,” he said. “This has been evident through our investment since 2021 in the Bullring itself and a programme of attracting the best brands and experiences to the city.”
But for many, including Dr McCabe, the debate is no longer just about development — it’s about identity. As cranes and construction reshape the skyline, the question remains: what kind of Birmingham will be left behind?
Dr Steve McCabe
Steve is Professor and Pro Vice Chancellor, DoctorateHub.
Previously, having worked for Birmingham City Council, he spent the last 35 years as an academic at Birmingham City University teaching and researching economics, management and business. Additionally, he has written extensively for edited texts examining economics and politics.
He regularly writes and comments regularly in the national and international media on politics and the economy and has published texts on quality management, benchmarking, ‘Brexit’ and its economic and social impact, the green economy and manufacturing, house prices and India’s progress since independence.
