The curse of ghost estates in Birmingham and West Midlands: New housing developments are failing communities
Dealing with the curse of ghost estates in Birmingham and the West Midlands, writes Dr Steve McCabe.
Last week, I delved into the contentious issue of the village of Dorridge and surrounding settlements merging to officially become a town.
I mused on the impact this will have if, as expected, it presages a vastly increased rate of housebuilding by developers. You can read more about this here.
Within my analysis, I made the point that it’s important to recognise that once houses are built in large numbers, they’ll be sold largely to families who’ll inevitably wish to avail of local services such as health, schools, and shops, which may, certainly in the short term, find it difficult to cope with a sudden increase in demand.
Government data indicates that Birmingham’s population will continue to grow and is projected to rise by 60,000 in the next 22 years meaning demand for housing is highly unlikely to abate from current levels, quite the contrary.


This raises the important question of where such housing should be built and the amenities and infrastructure that should accompany its construction.
Coincidentally, a couple of days after my piece, The Guardian published an article by Harriet Grant, ‘No shops, no schools’: homes in England built without basic amenities,’ in which she examined the tendency for new estates to be constructed without developers needing to immediately provide vital facilities and services.
As Grant explains, though there may be provision for the eventual construction of things like playgrounds, local shops, and health facilities and for ensuring new estates are connected by public transport, these may take years to transpire, leaving residents occupying the new houses in a form of limbo.
Sadly, she relates the case of a development outside the village of Cressing in Essex, where 225 new homes were built overlooking an unfinished playground that’s fenced off and around which signs have been erected making it clear that children should not use it.
She reports on one resident who informs her that despite the houses on the development being completed three years ago, the playground has remained unfinished ever since and that residents have given up hope of the developer ever coming back.
Additionally, the resident interviewed by Grant asserts that shops and a nursery promised have yet to materialise.
As if to emphasise the lifeless sense of the development, Grant points out recently planted trees have died.
It’s important to recognise that planning consent varies depending on the committee granting it, and there is no standard requirement to achieve in terms of the amenities that developers must construct.
However, whilst Grant acknowledges some developers not only provide exactly what was agreed at the planning stage—some exceeding their obligations—too many developers do not and, it seems, display extreme tardiness in fulfilling the need to complete the facilities and infrastructure that will make new estates places in which normal life and leisure take place.
That there’s a significant gap between the houses and the shops, pub, doctors’ surgery, and myriads of buildings and open space for play areas and exercise for adults gives the impression that new estates are soulless and lacking vitality.
Clearly, if such situations are to be avoided, planning committees need to more vigorously enforce all the conditions that were part of the consent to build new estates.
Arguments based on not having adequate resources or insufficient ability to impose sanctions are not acceptable.
It’s accepted that we need more houses to be built and that they should be affordable.
This is where we enter the realm of the economics of housebuilding.
Developers are profit-making businesses, which is perfectly acceptable.
What’s less easy to accept is that the housebuilding sector is now dominated by a handful of large national businesses that possess immense influence over the process, most especially in the purchase and use of land on which houses can be built.
In order to secure this land, developers, who have considerable commercial firepower and are therefore able to outbid smaller local builders who, until a generation ago, were much more active in the housebuilding sector, have pushed the price up.
Supply of land, the component of housebuilding that cannot be increased, has become precious and, in some cases, hoarded by developers.
This is their right, though some politicians contend more should be done to make developers use up their planning consents at a faster rate to increase the supply of houses.
Crucially, as businesses beholden to producing ‘acceptable rates of return on capital invested’ seek to build as fast as they can sell their product.
What is significant is that the footprint of houses has progressively decreased, meaning the configuration of houses has altered—a reason why some developers build three stories—and gardens have noticeably shrunk in all but the most expensive developments.
Consequently, families with young children find that there is less space for them to play, which makes the provision of parks and/or open space at the outset of the development all the more urgent.
In Grant’s report she quotes a spokesperson for the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government who, in restating the current government’s commitment to building 1.5 million homes in the lifetime of this Parliament, makes clear that developers should be held to account in their obligation to “make a development acceptable, regardless of size.”
This is hardly going to have the strategic managers of large development companies quaking in fear at the consequences of not fulfilling their obligations to the construction of essential infrastructure and community amenities.
Worryingly, it may be that the recently announced intention to relax planning regulations to unshackle developers could make it even easier for them to ignore what they should provide beyond building the houses they sell (and there’s no shortage of stories of those moving into new houses who discover many defects).
Ironically, it would appear, councils need even greater powers to build good-quality homes that are part of an integrated and carefully coordinated approach to creating the communities of tomorrow.
Reducing the need for people to commute and spend many hours getting to their place of work is part of this process.
Ideally, the government should be focusing on how to allow people to work and enjoy leisure within their local area.
Here in Birmingham, campaigners argued that appalling social and health problems caused by packing people together in insanitary conditions during the rapid expansion that occurred as part of the industrial revolution required urgent change.
Housing standards emerged, gardens were provided, frequently of pretty large size, and, significantly, so did green space (parks).
My own childhood in Sparkhill is of the time spent playing in our garden and, more particularly, the regular trips to the local park, which had a bandstand, tennis courts, and, until it was filled in, a massive paddling pool.
I recall that on Sunday afternoons the many Irish families would congregate there to relax in a setting that reminded those from rural areas of the green fields of home.


Such parks, which are a feature of all areas of Birmingham, did not come about by accident but by the determined efforts of campaigners to dedicate public open space as the city expanded.
The benefits to citizens were immense, and there’s a wealth of research demonstrating housing developed around open space in which communities can congregate is a vitally important investment.
Unfortunately, without sufficient willpower to radically shift our appreciation of public green space, the social benevolence of philanthropy by wealthy individuals such as Louisa Ryland, who donated Cannon Hill Park in 1873, as well as George Dawson and Robert Dale, who championed the need for parks, coupled with enthusiastic support from councillors within Birmingham Corporation in the late nineteenth century, will not be repeated.
As a direct consequence, we’ll see too many housing developments being built resembling, certainly until facilities and amenities vital to community cohesion are provided (willingly or by threat of sanctions), ‘ghost estates.’
Dr Steven McCabe
Steve is Professor and Pro Vice Chancellor, DoctorateHub.
Previously, having worked for Birmingham City Council, he spent the last 35 years as an academic at Birmingham City University teaching and researching economics, management and business. Additionally, he has written extensively for edited texts examining economics and politics.
He regularly writes and comments regularly in the national and international media on politics and the economy and has published texts on quality management, benchmarking, ‘Brexit’ and its economic and social impact, the green economy and manufacturing, house prices and India’s progress since independence.