What the Maccabi Tel Aviv Vs Aston Villa match has revealed about Birmingham’s fragile civic trust

Ultimately, the city, and by virtue, all its citizens, will suffer as a consequence, writes Dr Steve McCabe.

For any football fan the announcement of fixtures for their team is a source of potential excitement and, perhaps, some trepidation.

This sense is especially so in cup competitions, particularly in Europe, where the chances of being drawn against a side never played before increase.

So, when the teams Aston Villa would play in this year’s UEFA Europa League competition were announced at the end of last August, the odds of playing a new side shortened.

Among the teams to be played both home and away were some interesting teams, including Bologna, Feyenoord, Basel, Fenerbahce, Red Bull Salzburg and the intriguingly named Go Ahead Eagles, a Dutch professional football club from the city of Deventer, and a Swiss team, Young Boys.

However, Villa being drawn to play Israeli team Maccabi Tel Aviv at home on Thursday, 6th November, was not only of immediate interest to its fans and the club’s management but also to the West Midlands Police and local politicians.

Maccabi Tel Aviv, like any Israeli team, will be likely to create added tension when playing in Britain.

That Israeli teams play in Europe is a consequence of the 1967 Six-Day War, when Arab and Muslim nations refused to play against them and, in 1974, led to Israel’s expulsion from the Asian Football Confederation.

UEFA offered a way for Israeli clubs to play against European teams, firstly in the Intertoto Cup and, subsequent to achieving full membership in 1994, in the Champions League and Europa Cup.

However, the attack by Hamas on Israel on October 7th, 2023, resulted in 1,219 people being murdered, and 251 hostages taken by this terrorist group.

Hamas' attack led to an invasion of Gaza by Israeli Defence Forces in which, according to the Red Cross, over 69,000 have died, including at least 17,000 children, and in excess of 170,000 have been injured.

Understandably, any football match involving an Israeli team in Britain would raise serious questions as to the morality as well as concerning public safety.

But the fact that Maccabi Tel Aviv, a team whose fans have a reputation for passionate support for their team, were going to play a team based in a part of Birmingham in which local residents are largely non-white and among whom are a significant number of Muslims sympathetic to the plight of Palestinians, guaranteed them playing at Villa Park was always likely to be a combustible affair with the certainty of demonstrations and potential trouble.

Significantly, the game will be remembered more for the machinations of ‘evidence’ used to justify the ban on Maccabi Tel Aviv’s fans from attending their team’s encounter with Villa in Birmingham than the football played.

That there was opposition among many in Birmingham to Maccabi Tel Aviv being allowed to play at Villa Park last November is an understatement.

The local MP in whose constituency Villa Park is located, Pakistan-born British independent Ayoub Khan, who before successfully standing for Perry Barr in the 2024 general election as a pro-Gaza candidate had served as a Liberal Democrat councillor for Aston, was vociferous in his belief that Maccabi Tel Aviv should not be allowed to play Aston Villa.

Banning a football team on the basis of the actions carried out by the government of the country they come from is highly unusual.

Rather, it’s entirely legitimate to ban fans if their behaviour constitutes the risk of creating serious danger to public safety.

A group explicitly dedicated to examining risks associated with public events being held in Birmingham exists, the Safety Advisory Group (SAG), and consists of representatives of professional authorities with relevant expertise considered Maccabi Tel Aviv’s visit to Birmingham before it happened.

Chaired by Birmingham City Council's Head of Resilience, SAG sought the advice of the West Midlands Police (WMP) and, following two meetings on 7th and 16th October, made what has become the notorious decision on 24th October to ban Maccabi Tel Aviv fans from attending Villa Park on the basis of intelligence gleaned by WMP from Dutch police subsequent to a comparable fixture against Ajax in November 2024.

A number of lurid claims were made about what went on in Holland in November 2024, which, though there was indeed some conflict between pro-Palestinians and supporters of Maccabi Tel Aviv, resulting in a handful of injuries and almost 70 arrests, bears little comparison to the contents of the reports prepared by WMP for SAG last October.

What seems abundantly clear, especially in reading the report submitted to Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood by Sir Andy Cooke, HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary and HM Chief Inspector of Fire & Rescue Services, last Wednesday, ‘Inspection of police forces’ contributions to safety advisory groups: West Midlands Police’ , is the degree to which WMP have ensured that the intelligence they received from Dutch police has been, at best, overstated and, at worst, confected in order to paint as negative a picture of Maccabi Tel Aviv fans as possible.

A consequence of what has emerged, including a game which never happened being invested using AI – West Ham versus Maccabi Tel Aviv – as well as notes of meetings between WMP and the Dutch police going missing, portrays a force responsible for law and order and ensuring the ability of citizens to go about their lives in safety and with confidence severely undermined.

The upshot of what’s become clear in recent weeks is that the Chief Constable Craig Guildford has resigned as a direct result of losing the confidence of pretty much all local MPs, the leader of the council and, once she’d received Sir Andy’s report, Shabana Mahmood, who, notably, as well as being a Muslim, is also MP for Ladywood.

There are serious questions to be asked about the way in which Guildford and his senior officers went about the process of preparing their intelligence for SAG and, as some speculate, whether they had a conclusion that had been predetermined, i.e., banning Maccabi Tel Aviv’s fans, and then made the evidence fit.

Notably, WMP appear to have taken counsel from individuals whose public stance is to castigate Israel as frequently as they can and used this game as an opportunity to engage in what would seem to be antisemitism.

That there are reports that WMP were aware of individuals who were prepared to, if possible, attack members of the Maccabi Tel Aviv squad raises the question of why they have not been arrested.

At the very least the Jewish community in Birmingham and the West Midlands must feel let down.

It’s crucial that policing, regardless of the prevailing circumstances and challenges, should be carried out without fear nor favour.

Many will remember that the West Midlands Police, most particularly the Serious Crime Squad, disbanded by Sir Geoffrey Dear in 1989, created evidence to convict criminals it believed to be guilty.

What’s gone on as a consequence of the visit to Villa Park last November has created an aura of an untrustworthy police force in the second city and, I fear, has undermined community relations and done nothing to improve the relationship between Muslims and Jews in the West Midlands.

It has made the job of Police and Crime Commissioner Simon Foster, who currently oversees the role of policing in the West Midlands and whose role, like all other PCCs, will be disbanded in 2028, all the more difficult.

Those seeking an alternative solution to the established political parties will get an opportunity to vent their spleen in the local elections in May.

What we’ve witnessed in terms of policing the Maccabi Tel Aviv match will only cement the views of those who wish to vote for independent pro-Palestine candidates and, equally, those disillusioned by Labour and the Tories to support Reform.

I hope I’m proved wrong, but the prospect of there being no party in overall control in Birmingham has increased, and it’s hard to see any grand coalition being formed to ensure citizens receive the quality of services they deserve.

Ultimately, the city, and by virtue, all its citizens, will suffer as a consequence.

Perhaps the West Midlands Police thought by, mistakenly or otherwise, deceiving the SAG it would serve the greater good to exclude Maccabi Tel Aviv supporters.

Unfortunately, for us all, the use of confected/invented evidence has come back to bite those who used it for whatever reason they thought it would serve.

As the well-known line from Sir Walter Scott's 1808 poem Marmion, "Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practise to deceive!"

Dr Steve McCabe

Steve is Professor and Pro Vice Chancellor, DoctorateHub.

Previously, having worked for Birmingham City Council, he spent the last 35 years as an academic at Birmingham City University teaching and researching economics, management and business. Additionally, he has written extensively for edited texts examining economics and politics.

He regularly writes and comments regularly in the national and international media on politics and the economy and has published texts on quality management, benchmarking, ‘Brexit’ and its economic and social impact, the green economy and manufacturing, house prices and India’s progress since independence. 

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice