Birmingham vs Manchester: The rivalry for England's second city reignited by YouTuber

The debate over which city deserves the title of England’s "second city" has raged for decades. While Birmingham has traditionally claimed this position due to its size, history, and economic importance, Manchester’s rise as a cultural and industrial powerhouse has fuelled a heated rivalry.

One vocal advocate for Manchester’s claim is street vlogger Charlie Veitch, who argues that Manchester’s influence and modern innovation make it the rightful heir to the "second city" crown. In a recent video, he highlighted the city's contributions to culture, sport, and technological advancements, sparking renewed discussion.

Watch the video as we take the streets of Birmingham to ask: “Birmingham or Manchester for the Second City title - and why?”.

Birmingham, the largest city outside London, boasts a rich industrial heritage, a thriving culinary scene, and iconic landmarks such as the Bullring and Cadbury World.

Its central location and role as a transport hub further cement its status. However, Manchester has carved out its place on the global stage with its vibrant music scene, world-renowned universities, and dominance in football through clubs like Manchester United and Manchester City.

Meanwhile, Birmingham locals remain steadfast in their belief that their city holds the edge. “We’ve always been the heart of industry and innovation in this country,” said one resident. Others pointed to Birmingham’s diversity, its arts and theatre scene, and its growing reputation as a culinary destination as reasons for its enduring status.

Ultimately, the debate reveals how both cities bring unique strengths and identities to the table. For some, the title of "second city" may depend on personal preference - whether they value the historic significance of Birmingham or the cultural vibrancy and modernity of Manchester.

What do you think? Let us know at [email protected].

Get the latest headlines delivered straight to your inbox with BirminghamWorld’s free newsletter