I refuse to stay silent as Birmingham neighbourhood named the most crime-ridden in the country

Dr Steven McCabe wades in after a Birmingham neighbourhood has been dubbed the most crime-ridden in the country.

The expression lies, damned lies and statistics, intended to provide a warning that figures – ‘hard facts’ – can mislead us, is a case in point that accepted wisdom is not always what we believe it to be.

The origin of this expression is usually attributed it to British politician Benjamin Disraeli (1804-1881) who twice served as prime minister.

However, as often happens with wonderfully evocative utterances, there’s no evidence Disraeli ever claimed statistics can be manipulated or made to present a preferred story or message.

According to a recent report in the Daily Mail, ‘England and Wales's most dangerous streets’, Birmingham’s Ladywood has the greatest incidence of crime in England and Wales.

Apparently, recorded crime statistics show that in 2024, 1,782 violent or sexual crimes were committed in the Ladywood area meaning, on average, five people were attacked or assaulted every day.

Pointedly, the Daily Mail article in the first sentence of this article states that New Street, arguably the main thoroughfare through our city, ‘is the most crime-ridden neighbourhood in England and Wales’.

It’s worth remembering that New Street is included in the Ladywood constituency and that for the purpose of carrying out analysis, the Daily Mail explains that ‘powered with official statistics’ the interactive map is divided into 'Lower layer Super Output Areas' (LSOAs) which are communities of between 1,000 and 3,000 people.

This is in addition to West Midlands Police recording the highest rate of knife crime offences in England and Wales last year.

Unfortunately, anyone reading the Mail’s article on crime is hardly likely to be enticed to want to visit Birmingham.

Nonetheless, and whilst I have no issue with the statistics that have been used, they are measuring very serious offences which, thankfully, very few of us are likely to be victims of.

It’s undoubtedly the case that when considering any inner-city area, that there are massively entrenched issues of deprivation which impact on crime statistics.

Accordingly, whilst it’s very easy for the Daily Mail to use ‘weaponise’ crime statistics to claim that a casual visitor to Birmingham city centre is in danger of being attacked, the reality is that it’s no less safe as any other major city or town.

Indeed, how many of us have heard stories of having been pickpocketed – not a regarded as a serious crime – in many major European cities?

Clearly dealing with crime is a major challenge confronting the current government as well as our local policy makers.

To borrow from a certain Labour politician, what’s absolutely vital is to be tough on crime but tough on the causes.

Lighthorne Avenue in Ladywoodplaceholder image
Lighthorne Avenue in Ladywood | Anita Maric / SWNS

More deterrents are certainly required in terms of visible policing though, of course, we don’t want to resemble a military state!

Anecdotally, in speaking to someone with a teenage son, he told me that he’d been informed by him that because of the presence of police and security, Birmingham feels safer that Solihull where he lives.

What is damning is that there’s a distinct lack of prospects for far too many young people in Birmingham.

This, of course, is not a new problem and something politicians locally and nationally continue to be intensely concerned about.

However, translating such concerns into action that will vastly improve the loves of those blighted is difficult to achieve.

This city is, on average, the youngest in Europe and its incumbent to continue to work towards making Birmingham a place where investment and entrepreneurship thrive, a major objective of the Birmingham City Council and the West Midlands Mayor Richard Parker.

However, the fact we’re in the midst of another financial crisis which, it appears, will probably get a great deal worse before it gets better – especially if money desperately needed for improving communities is siphoned off for more military spending to defend ourselves against Russia – and make matters infinitely worse.

The statistics contained in the Daily Mail’s report are, at face value, shocking but should not blind us to the magnitude of the social crisis and malaise affected young people in Birmingham.

Richard Murphy who, on his website Funding the Future, considers why young people are so disillusioned in this country and unwilling to fight for it if there was a war.

As he asks, why would they be willing to make the ultimate sacrifice for a country that’s sold them short and has caused many to live in poverty due to of austerity as well as denying them free education to study at university?

Why he contends, would those on zero-hours contracts and the “prospect of the minimum wage for life” fight to defend that a country with significantly reduced prospects for the future when compared to the parents’ generation?

As Murphy points out, home ownership, something former PM Margaret Thatcher who’s cited as having done so much to undermine manufacturing in this city, regarded as a key aspiration for all citizens, has massively reduced since the global financial crisis that occurred almost two decades ago.

To boot, councils such as Birmingham have not been able to build sufficient numbers of good quality social housing.

These are the realities of currently being young in this country and provide a stark context for the crime statistics reported on by the Daily Mail.

Readers should fully appreciate the difficulties young people must deal with before fulminating about what they see as fecklessness and the end of society as we know it; precisely what was said about Teddy Boys in the 1950s.

We should also ask ourselves why there’s so much homelessness, particularly affecting young people, on every high street in Birmingham.

So, I would suggest, it’s incumbent on all of us to collectively engage in urgent action to make Birmingham is seen as a place we’re proud of and that it’s a city people want to visit.

After all, we have an incredibly rich industrial history as well as our contribution to civic pride and culture, particularly in music.

It’s vital we use every opportunity to highlight diversity and our immense potential for innovation and creativity.

This is the narrative outsiders should hear in order to balance the dreadful crime statistics contained in the article recently published in the Daily Mail.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice