How we rated West Brom’s 10 new summer signings so far - part two

We’ve given Albion’s 10 new summer signings a grade for how their season has gone at the one-third stage of the campaign - see part two and the second load of the five signings below, and how they compare to the ratings we dished out in September.

We have updated our gradings of Albion’s 10 summer signings after dishing out early term reports during the previous international break.

Players are listed in order of signing date. See part two below featuring the most recent five summer recruits, part one was published yesterday. The grading in brackets is how the Express & Star rated the players during the previous international break, at the end of September.

The previous rankings can be viewed here.

Felix Horn Myhre (D+)

Not alone in this list in having enjoyed a superb rise in the last six weeks or so.

Horn Myhre arrived to much promise and was given a regular run in the side by James Morrison and while an honest worker and performer, the Norwegian had been unable to bring the desired end product to performances.

Felix Horn Myhre scored a deft goal against Millwall next time out.placeholder image
Felix Horn Myhre scored a deft goal against Millwall next time out. | PA

The attacking midfielder missed a gilt-edged opportunity against Birmingham but responded with the late winner from the bench against Blackburn. He then scored in wins over West Ham and Millwall and has provided assists too.

Horn Myhre’s progress has been impressive and the challenge is more of the same.

C+

Rabby Nzingoula (C+)

Rated reasonably well last time out and he has certainly kicked on in the last half-a-dozen outings.

The Frenchman put in particularly fine displays in the last three games against West Ham, Southampton and Millwall. He appears to have settled well in the otherwise unclaimed right-sided role. His more natural game is centrally and may now have a run after Ousmane Diakite’s injury.

Nzingoula is exciting Baggies supporters with his vibrant game, full of pace and trickery and, at just 20, there is much more to come from the former Strasbourg man.

He must bring more end product to his game and find himself on the scoresheet, or create more goals, but at the moment his progress has been eye-catching.

B-

Kareem Tunde (D-)

Kareem Tunde has been bright of late and put in a fine display against Millwall.Photographer Rich Linley / CameraSport
placeholder image
Kareem Tunde has been bright of late and put in a fine display against Millwall.Photographer Rich Linley / CameraSport | World Copyright © 2026 CameraSport. All rights reserved. 43 Linden Ave. Countesthorpe. Leicester. England. LE8 5PG - Tel: +44 (

Rated low down last time out while struggling to find his feet and build up fitness and adapt to the English game.

But a few cameos of late - notably in the impressive 3-0 Millwall win - have changed the mood around the 21-year-old Spaniard.

Left-footed Tunde played his part in two goals in an electric 15 minutes against the Lions and finally looks at home. His adaptation is understandable given the young age and new surroundings.

Morrison needs his creative spark as an alternate option on the flank. The head coach has full belief Tunde can deliver - it feels like an important month or two for the youngster.

D+

Toby Collyer (B-)

Rated highly following a bright first appearance against QPR last time out, and fared reasonably well against Wrexham and Birmingham, but a huge blow followed thereafter.

Collyer fell to a hamstring issue against Blackburn, to which Morrison claimed a share of the responsibility.

Toby Collyer pulled up injured against Blackburn last month.placeholder image
Toby Collyer pulled up injured against Blackburn last month. | Iconic Media resell

It is the latest fitness blow for the former Manchester United man, who endured more than one on loan last season.

Given this week’s untimely Diakite calf setback, the Baggies hope Collyer will be back and ready to make his mark before long.

D+

Brayann Pereira (E-)

As reflected by his grade, the French right-back has come a long way since the red card half hour into his debut at Derby.

Pereira, the deadline day recruit from NEC Nijmegen in The Netherlands, has quickly banished fears from his rash Baggies bow and settled into a right-back berth impressively.

Albion's Brayann Pereira has been impressive during an extended run in the side.placeholder image
Albion's Brayann Pereira has been impressive during an extended run in the side. | PA

Given the hurried transition after the nightmare season-ending Nolan Galves knee injury, Pereira’s adjustment to the English game has been impressive. The 23-year-old looks a physically capable right-back, solid defensively, and happy to support in the final third.

With little depth underneath Pereira, Albion must keep him fit.

B-

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice