James Bond - Is Pattinson just a little too pale and pasty to take on the role?
Roshan Doug on James Bond and why he’s not sure Robert Pattinson is the right man for the job
You might have learnt earlier this week that the new James Bond will be played by Robert Pattinson. Like me, you might have wondered: Robert who?
To be honest, I was rooting for Henry Cavill, the actor who played Superman for 10 years from 2013.
Apparently, Pattinson played Batman in the 2022 film. I’ve looked at a few pictures of him and, frankly, he looks more like someone who might approach your car at traffic lights asking for spare change than a man capable of rescuing the world from international terrorism.
Pattinson is rather pale, painfully thin-looking and hardly the imposing figure you’d expect to see ordering a vodka martini before taking on a dozen heavily armed villains. Of course, appearances can be deceptive. Perhaps there’s a muscular action hero lurking beneath that gaunt exterior. If not, I’m sure the producers will put him through a punishing regime of exercise and diet before filming begins next year.
Ian Fleming’s action hero is an iconic character and has a certain male appeal. Since the first film, Dr No, in 1962, how many men, when putting on an evening suit, haven’t rehearsed the immortal words: ‘The name’s Bond, James Bond’? And who hasn’t stood in front of a mirror, turned sideways, fashioned their fingers into a shape of a pistol and attempted that familiar gunshot pose before the opening credits?
When I was growing up, practically every schoolboy wanted to be 007. Bond wasn’t simply fictional. He was an aspiration: confident, courageous, impeccably dressed, quick-witted and seemingly impervious to danger.


That’s partly why I’m not bowled over by Pattinson’s appointment, nor am I particularly impressed by the direction in which the franchise has been travelling.
Somewhere along the way, Bond seems to have become a victim of modern fashions.
Timothy Dalton started the process, and Daniel Craig took it considerably further. Both seemed to mistake emotional vulnerability for character development. Their Bonds became far too emotionally invested in the women they were supposed to seduce, use and occasionally abandon.
Craig, in particular, seemed to have attended one too many sessions of emotional counselling. Though popular with women, he was brooding, introspective and increasingly sentimental. To me, he was in danger of becoming a little wokeish.


The traditional Bond was a rather different animal. He enjoyed women, certainly, but wasn’t emotionally dependent on them. He went his own way, answered to nobody and lived a relatively unfettered existence. He was a real man’s man: independent, adventurous, self-assured and comfortable in his own skin. He could be charming without being needy, romantic without being sentimental and dangerous without having to explain himself. We didn’t need him to discuss his feelings every five minutes.
My personal favourite Bond was always that played by Roger Moore. He had the English accent, impeccable tailoring, raised eyebrow and wonderfully dry, tongue-in-cheek remarks.
He was lively. He could be in the middle of a gunfight, facing certain death, and still manage a quip. There was something delightfully charming and frivolous about his interpretation. He didn’t take himself too seriously, and neither did he expect us to.


Sean Connery, on the other hand, never quite did it for me. I found him rather cold and detached, and his broad, sometimes slurred Scottish accent wasn’t what I associated with the sophisticated British secret agent. I also have a rather less flattering personal association with him.
A former girlfriend of mine once spotted Connery in Los Angeles. Excitedly, she rushed to him from the other side of the street to ask for his autograph. His response, apparently, was to tell her to ‘f*** off’. Not quite the behaviour of the gentlemanly secret agent we had come to admire. Perhaps he was having a bad day, but she certainly wouldn’t have minded a pinch of Roger Moore’s charm.
Of course, Bond has always had his critics. His treatment of women, drinking, smoking, gambling and general disregard for health and safety might not pass muster with today’s public health officials, social commentators or the MeToo movement. But that was rather the point. He was a fictional character, not a government-approved lifestyle adviser.
Perhaps that’s the trouble with the modern world. In an ever-decreasing male spaces, Bond was a beacon of light. And in our eagerness to reinterpret everything, we sometimes forget why we admired him in the first place. Not everything needs to be softened, sanitised or brought into line with the prevailing fashions of the day. Some characters are best left with their imperfections, their contradictions and their particular magic.
Bond belonged to an age when a man’s character was measured by his courage, his composure and his ability to face danger with a smile rather than a therapy session. Yes that age has passed. But I hope it hasn’t disappeared altogether. After all, fashions come and go, governments change and cultural orthodoxies have their day.
And anyway, who wouldn’t want to see a bit of class, style and penchant interspersed with car chases, action and explosions? And remember – Cavill or no Cavill: a little courage, elegance, wit and old-fashioned roguishness never really go out of style. Nor, I suspect, should James Bond.
* Roshan Doug is an educationalist and social commentator. He is also a former Birmingham Poet Laureate