‘I’ve killed my padmate’: Life sentence for Shropshire prison killer who strangled ‘quiet and decent’ cell mate

The killer was described as “eerily nonchalant” after alerting prison officers

A mentally disordered inmate found guilty of murdering his cellmate has been sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 16 years.

Jonathan Alcide, 36, killed Neil Ashby at HMP Stoke Heath, near Market Drayton, in July last year despite the 49-year-old victim’s efforts to get help for his killer, whose mental health conditions included depression and psychosis.

A trial at Stafford Crown Court which ended in September heard that Mr Ashby had told fellow prisoners he was worried about Alcide’s mental health in the weeks before he was strangled at some point on the evening of June 30 or in the early hours of July 1.

Alcide was described by a prison officer as eerily nonchalant after he alerted staff that Mr Ashby was dead by ringing the buzzer in their cell at 6.12am on July 1 and saying: “I’ve killed my padmate”.

Jonathan Alcideplaceholder image
Jonathan Alcide | West Mercia Police

He denied murder, claiming he was not guilty by reason of insanity.

In a victim impact statement, read to the court by a barrister before sentencing, Mr Ashby’s younger brother Dean, who lives in the US, said it felt like he and his parents had lost everything.

He said: “We grieve and cry for Neil every single day since he was cruelly taken away from us. I have lost the kindest and most loving person I have ever known.”

Wearing a maroon long-sleeved jumper on Tuesday, Alcide was allowed to represent himself, telling the court in mitigation: “I have to accept my actions have caused Neil’s death.

“Neil was a good man - kind, caring and generous. I spent a lot of time working on my mental health beforehand. I had no access to anything to mitigate the deterioration of mental health I experienced.”

The trial heard that fellow Stoke Heath prisoners described Mr Ashby as “quiet and decent” and a “nice lad” who had declined multiple cell moves despite raising concerns about Alcide’s mental health.

Stoke Heath Prisonplaceholder image
Stoke Heath Prison

Mr Ashby, who brought Alcide meals after he stopped leaving his room, told fellow inmates his cellmate had started to read the Quran, was becoming scared of God and having suicidal thoughts.

Before passing a life sentence, Judge Avik Mukherjee said the defendant had intended to kill Mr Ashby and the murder was aggravated by a previous conviction for causing grievous bodily harm, and the fact that the victim “was vulnerable because he was in a locked cell”.

The judge said: “Neil Ashby wanted to stay sharing a cell with you because he was concerned about you.

“The taking of a life is a terrible thing. It’s plain that losing Neil Ashby has been devastating for his family and their lives will never be the same again.

“Only you know the full detail of what happened between you and Neil Ashby in cell 13 that night.”

Alcide, who was serving a sentence at the time of the murder for an attack on his mother, attempted to address the court further before being led away to the cells.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice