Blow for West Midlands buskers as £500 fines approved

Against this backdrop, a committee at Birmingham Council this week approved a fixed penalty amount of £500 for a breach in the city.

A proposed rise for PSPO fines which could see buskers ordered to pay £500 if they play in certain Birmingham streets has been approved.

There are several Public Spaces Protection Orders in place across the city, which each one cracking down on particular behaviours within certain areas.

One order, designed to tackle street noise by banning musical instruments and amplification in a number of city centre streets, was introduced last year under a cloud of controversy.

The council said the crackdown was necessary because it had previously received a “significant and consistent number of complaints” from residents and businesses about noise issues.

But buskers and musicians have slammed the move and urged the council to rethink it amid fears of ‘spontaneous joy’ being ‘crushed’ in the heart of Birmingham.

David Fisher, who has been busking in Brum for 15 years, protested the order only earlier this month, arguing that musicians are struggling and “being criminalised” by it.

Concerns among buskers have also recently been heightened after the government recently increased the upper limit for a PSPO fine.

Against this backdrop, a committee at Birmingham Council this week approved a fixed penalty amount of £500 for a breach in the city.

This means anyone who breaches a PSPO in Birmingham – including the one which bans musical instruments and amplification in a number of streets – will soon pay up £500, rather than the current £100 fine.

A council officer told a meeting on Wednesday that the street noise PSPO in was introduced because the city centre has “become much more residential”.

“As a result, a number of residents in the city centre were affected by statutory noise nuisance,” he said. “We are required in law to take action to abate that nuisance.”

He continued that prior to the order being introduced, it was difficult to tackle the noise because the people causing it would change regularly.

On the possibility of a consent scheme being introduced for buskers, the officer said: “London has a specific piece of legislation which enables [such a scheme] to be done.

“We don’t have that unfortunately.”

He continued that the council has been working with the busking community and various organisations to try and find a compromise.

“None of those organisations have come up with anything that’s workable in the city centre,” he said. “One of the problems is if we don’t have the PSPO, we go back to having the nuisance and back to the local authority being required to take action.”

On how fines are issued, the officer said: “It isn’t expected that everybody will know an area is covered with a PSPO.

“We bring it to [a person’s] attention, we ask them to stop [certain activities] and then after a period of time if they haven’t desisted, that would be the breach.”

£500 fine ‘is considered proportionate’

Explaining why the PSPO fine increase was recommended for approval, a council report said a £500 tariff is “considered proportionate to the seriousness and often continuing nature of the behaviour”.

“[It also remains] an alternative to prosecution rather than an additional punishment.”

Members of the committee also agreed that no reduced amount would be offered for early payment.

“No early-payment reduction is proposed,” it said.

“Previous experience with discounted fixed penalties has created administrative difficulty where payments are made outside the discounted period or as part payments.

“A single amount is clearer, more consistent and easier to administer.”

The report went on to say that setting a fine between £100 and £500 was considered.

But officers at the council concluded: “This would produce a lower financial penalty but may not adequately reflect the seriousness of the conduct for which PSPOs are used.

“A lower amount could also reduce the distinction between compliance at the warning stage and the consequences of a subsequent criminal breach.”

Following the licensing and public protection committee’s decision to approve the plans, the £500 will apply only to the fixed penalty notices issued on or after November 23.

The increase in the penalty applies to all PSPOs – not just the one which focuses on street noise.

A Birmingham City Council spokesperson said: “Busking is welcome on most public land in Birmingham, but a PSPO places restrictions on the use of musical instruments and amplification within a defined area of the city centre.

“These measures are intended to address excessive noise and balance the needs of performers with those of residents, businesses and visitors.

“We ask all buskers to consider their impact on others to ensure busking is enjoyable for all people in the vicinity.”

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice