'We do not need a McDonald’s, keep Stirchley independent' - Petition and protest against fast food chain bid

Stirchley, a Birmingham suburb renowned for its thriving high street of independent businesses, is at the centre of a heated debate over plans for a new McDonald’s restaurant.

While formal proposals are yet to be submitted, the fast-food giant has outlined plans to develop a drive-thru restaurant with parking spaces on a vacant brownfield site.

Read more: Public consultation opens for new McDonald's in Stirchley

The idea has sparked strong opposition within the community, with more than 1,000 residents signing a petition against the development.

Many locals argue that Stirchley’s distinctive appeal lies in its lack of corporate chains, which has allowed independent businesses to flourish and helped the area earn the title of the Midlands’ best place to live in the Sunday Times guide.

Selly Oak MP Al Carns has joined the chorus of objectors, citing concerns over high childhood obesity rates, increased litter, and the potential threat to local businesses.

“The people of Stirchley have spoken up against this proposal, and as their representative in Government, I will amplify their voice. We do not need a McDonald’s in Stirchley,” Carns said in a statement.

Some residents also pointed out the proximity of existing McDonald’s outlets within a two-mile radius, questioning the need for another branch in the area.

On Tuesday, November 19, around 50 protesters braved freezing temperatures to gather on Pershore Road, waving placards and listening to speeches opposing the project.

Demonstrators emphasized that Stirchley’s identity as a community-driven, independent hub would be at risk if the proposal moves forward.

However, not everyone is against the idea. Supporters argue that the new McDonald’s would bring economic benefits, including the creation of up to 100 jobs and £45,000 in annual business rates.

As Stirchley grapples with the prospect of welcoming an international fast-food chain, the debate highlights the tension between economic development and preserving local character.

For now, the community remains deeply divided over what the future holds for its cherished high street.

Get in touch to share your views at [email protected]