We ask Birmingham: Would you serve if called up? Strong views on military conflict amid Russia tensions

Watch this: Birmingham reacts when we ask “Would you serve if called to war?”

With rising concerns over a potential conflict involving Russia, we took to the streets of Birmingham to ask locals if they would serve if called upon.

The responses revealed strong opinions but a divided public, with many young people expressing outright refusal, while others reflected on duty, patriotism, and scepticism toward political motives.

One resident summed up the dilemma many feel: "I'm a bit split, a bit 50-50 because, yes, doing something right for our country is an amazing thing, but on the other side, is it our fight, is it our war?"

The question of whether Britain should involve itself in such a conflict is a divisive one.

For some, the idea of mandatory service is non-negotiable. "Don't give the choice… under 21 and you're in for two years mandatory, unless you have a disability of course," said Gary Foster. Others, however, were more cynical, believing that serving would only benefit politicians rather than ordinary citizens. "What so many people don't seem to realise is that we would no longer be fighting for our country or our principles. We would be fighting to keep our politicians and their mates nice and comfortable whilst the rest of us suffer," argued Alan Wilkinson, who, despite being over 70, stated he would still fight for "the weak, the oppressed, for honour and integrity."

The generational divide was stark. Many older respondents recalled past service or expressed regret that the younger generation might not share the same willingness to defend the nation. "I'm nearly 60; I’d definitely go. This generation couldn’t win a raffle," said Graham Barrie. Similarly, John Griffiths, at 67, commented, "I don't think many of our young men would want to go—nothing like the men in the 14-18 and 39-45 wars."

In contrast, some younger individuals were less inclined to see military service as their responsibility. "Not this country, not anymore. It hates anyone born here, so why should me and mine fight to put cash in politicians' bank accounts? No from me - I’ll take my nice warm cell," declared Jason Houghton.

A recurring sentiment was the difference between defending Britain directly and fighting in a foreign war. "If it was to protect our country, fair enough. But why should our young people do it if it has nothing to do with us?" asked Poppy S. Watkins. Similarly, Vivien Shortland stated, "Yes, home guard at a beach town - I’d stop all invaders."

For others, there was no question about serving if it meant protecting civilians. "100% to protect women, children, and the vulnerable!! We are a very powerful country when it comes to it! We don’t run!" declared Sean Fleming.

Beyond patriotism, there was a strong undercurrent of political scepticism. Some suggested alternative solutions to war altogether. "The ones in conflict - world leaders - should fight it out and not use the population as cannon fodder. After all, what does it solve?" argued Susanne Bird.

The responses from Birmingham highlight the complexity of the issue. While some remain steadfast in their willingness to serve, others question the morality, necessity, and political motivations behind such conflicts.

As tensions rise on the global stage, the conversation about military service in the UK is only likely to intensify.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice