West Midlands Railway enters public ownership: What it means for passengers
What will becoming publicly owned mean for users of West Midlands Trains? - Dr Steve McCabe explains.
That operation of West Midlands Trains, transferred into public ownership on Sunday 1st February at the conclusion of the contract between the government and Transport UK Group and Mitsui & Co, now to be managed by DfT Operator Ltd (DFTO), is likely to have been met with indifference by the vast majority of commuters using the service who want them to be affordable and reliable.
As a press release from the Department of Transport announcing this change explained, “Public ownership of the railways will deliver an improved experience for passengers by bringing together train operators and the management of the railway’s infrastructure to improve performance, reduce subsidy, promote innovation and improve satisfaction, making the railway better for customers and taxpayers.”
So, what’s going to change?
In a nutshell, not very much, certainly in the short-term.
West Midlands Trains Limited will continue to operate commuter and local services in the West Midlands region as well as the West Coast Main Line between London and the Northwest under two trading names, West Midlands Railway (WMR) and London Northwestern Railway (LNR), respectively.
West Midlands Trains and those employed will now be controlled by DfT Operator Limited (DFTO), a government-owned holding company, as part of the Starmer administration’s manifesto pledge to renationalise the country’s railways if it won the general election.
There’s certainly plenty of evidence of services provided by privately owned companies giving less than outstanding service.
Franchise holders operating trains have featured prominently in the news.
In recent years there can be very few commuters in Birmingham and the West Midlands who’ve not experienced frustration and anger in discovering their train journey will be either delayed or cancelled and requires altering their plans.
There are some who’d prefer to commute to work by train, but the fear of being late means they instead resort to using a vehicle, adding to congestion on roads.
So, what’s the background to the change in operation of West Midlands Trains?
Significantly, DfT Operator Ltd was not established by this government and was created in May 2018 – when Theresa May was PM – when Secretary of State for Transport Chris Grayling believed that to fulfil section 30 of the Railways Act 1993 in ensuring continuity of rail services should a franchise fail, a separate government-backed company was necessary.
This effectively tells us that railways, like many other essential public services, cannot be allowed to disappear and that the Conservative government, traditionally seen as an advocate of privatisation, was willing to countenance public ownership of rail companies if, because of running at a loss, they folded, or their services were so dreadful they had their contracts terminated or not renewed.
Under the Conservatives, four train companies become subsidiaries of DfT Operator Limited: London North Eastern Railway (June 2018), Northern Trains (March 2020), Southeastern (October 2021), and TransPennine Express (May 2023).
On taking up office in July 2024, then Secretary of State for Transport Louise Haig announced that DfT Operator Ltd would manage train companies taken under public ownership as part of a process of transition into what would collectively be known as Great British Railways (GBR), a concept first mooted in 2021 in a white paper when Boris Johnson was PM.
West Midlands Trains is the fourth to have become part of this process, following South Western Railway (May 2025), c2c (July 2025), and Greater Anglia (October 2025).
Another six companies are scheduled to come under public control in the next two years.
Cynics may, with some justification, assert that what this government is effectively recreating is British Rail (BR).
BR, a public sector organisation which was created under the Transport Act 1947, nationalised the four largest privately owned rail companies – Great Western Railway, London, Midland & Scottish Railway, London & North Eastern Railway and Southern Railway – as well as other smaller operators as part of a commitment by Clement Atlee’s Labour government to wrest control from those frequently accused of not operating in the interests of the collective good of the country.
Until and throughout the Second World War, the rail system was seen as critical in enabling people and goods, including munitions essential in the fight against the Nazis, to be transported by train to all parts of Great Britain.
After 1945, car ownership, previously viewed as a luxury item by the majority, steadily rose, and train use by passengers declined, causing BR’s losses to vastly increase.
Many lines, particularly in remote rural areas, never made enough to cover costs.
A report, the "Modernisation Plan", was published in January 1955 to create a plan for a rationalised and up-to-date system capable of attracting more customers to eliminate financial losses borne by BR which, inevitably, were picked up by the government, i.e., taxpayers, by 1962.
Key to success was investment (£1.2 billion, now almost £28 billion according to the Bank of England calculator) to electrify main lines, which would allow faster, more reliable, and less dirty steam trains, and to replace all steam locomotives with diesel throughout the system, as well as replacing passenger and freight rolling stock with modern equivalents.
Allied to this was the need for new signalling and track marshalling yards.
As had been widely speculated, lines would need to close.
For many communities, their fears concerning this were confirmed following the publication of what’s usually referred to as the ‘Beeching Report’ in 1963, The Reshaping of British Railways, which directly resulted in the closure of 4,500 to 5,000 miles of rail lines, over two-fifths and over half of all stations.
Christian Wolmar, in his magnificent and authoritative book British Rail: A New History (published by Penguin Random House in 2022), explains that starved of vital funds and investment, BR staff were valiantly forced to make the best of the resources they had.
A consequence was that BR became the butt of many jibes, not all absolutely accurate, concerning reliability and efficiency, quality of food, and willingness of staff to assist passengers.
In the 1970s and 80s, BR increasingly seemed to be unable to raise its game to be comparable to the level of rail service offered in, most particularly, Europe, where we increasingly travelled for holidays and business.
Any investment from the government was directed at producing faster trains, such as the InterCity 125, which travelled on lines between major cities.
Cross-country lines, most particularly those going between the west and east (and vice versa), suffered as funds were directed to such prestige projects, some of which were spectacular failures, such as the Advanced Passenger Train (APT), capable of high speeds on existing 19th-century tracks which had bends using hydraulic tilting technology and, despite costing £50 million, was abandoned in 1985.
Individuals travelling by train, the main income source as freight moved to the road, steadily hovered at 700 million between 1975 and 1995.
Eventually, exactly half a century after its creation in 1947, then PM John Major announced the privatisation of BR.
Management of track, signalling and stations was carried out by Railtrack, the passenger services being operated by a number of privately owned companies which tendered for the right to run lines or regions, as was the case here in the West Midlands until midnight on 31st January.
Notably, following a series of catastrophically fatal accidents, Railtrack was placed into ‘railway administration’ under the Railways Act 1993 and became publicly owned in October 2001.
Running the railways is, it’s apparent, a hugely complex and expensive business and one, argued by advocates of public ownership, beyond the financial capability of privately owned companies possessing limited resources and in which the focus is all too often the short-term goal of return on investment.
So, on that basis alone, we should welcome the fact that West Midlands Trains is now publicly owned and will be part of the vision of Great British Railways.
However, before we engage in any sense of unbridled nostalgia about the good old days of BR, let’s not forget that back in the 1950s, 60s and 70s, when money for public investment was far more plentiful than it is now, the overall system, most particularly on local and regional lines such as here in the West Midlands, was only capable of operation because of the dedication of staff and a ‘make do and mend’ mentality.
John Major, writing in May 2008 and quoted in Christian Wolmar’s book, believed privatisation would “improve British Rail through the use of private sector skills, thereby making it possible to raise funds for investment from the market, in sums a publicly-funded [sic] railway could never have managed.”
As Major continues, and similarly to the message contained in the communication released by DfT Operator Limited concerning the transfer of ownership of West Midlands Trains, “in short: my purpose was to produce a better railway.”
Ultimately, the proof will be in how much change occurs in the quest to achieve a system of trains that works more efficiently and reliably and ensures people are incentivised to use them in preference to cars, which contribute to the congestion anyone travelling around the West Midlands experiences on a daily basis.
That infrastructure for transport is utterly essential for any society to function effectively, and underpinning economic benefits vital for employment, business creation and future investment is beyond argument.
Making comparisons with other countries is fine, but we should be aware that where there are excellent, affordable and integrated publicly funded transport systems, they have been created over generations in the belief that taxpayers there willingly accept that such investment is collectively and economically beneficial.
The current government stresses its commitment to investing in public services but says that it is stymied by the parlous state of public finances left by the previous administration.
There’s a danger of being in a process of never-ending flip-flopping driven by the whims of whichever administration is in power.
Rather, there needs to be a dedicated focus on what our society and economy need to function effectively and create a long-term strategy all major parties actively support.
Allied to that, I’d suggest, would be a willingness to consider radical thinking and innovation in all forms of transport in the quest to create sustainable and efficient transport.
Do I think this is likely to happen?
Sadly, past and current experiences don’t augur well.
Nonetheless, we can live in hope and must fervently hope that here in the West Midlands, commuters’ experience of travelling on trains in the future will be vastly improved by the fact that for the first time in almost 30 years, they are once again in public ownership.
Dr Steve McCabe
Steve is Professor and Pro Vice Chancellor, DoctorateHub.
Previously, having worked for Birmingham City Council, he spent the last 35 years as an academic at Birmingham City University teaching and researching economics, management and business. Additionally, he has written extensively for edited texts examining economics and politics.
He regularly writes and comments regularly in the national and international media on politics and the economy and has published texts on quality management, benchmarking, ‘Brexit’ and its economic and social impact, the green economy and manufacturing, house prices and India’s progress since independence.