Analysis: West Brom stand firm but draw line and move on from testing EFL ordeal

The written reasons for Albion’s points deduction have been published.

Being in receipt of the written reasons and confirming the decision not to appeal allows Albion the welcome opportunity to draw a line under an extremely frustrating ordeal.

Securing Championship status on the field under James Morrison always left it likely that the club would see fit not to appeal the deduction.

Albion continue to maintain their innocence - or at least they did not knowingly or willingly breach profit and sustainability regulations.

They remain frustrated by the questionable timing of the episode and the “grossly unfair” change in interpretation when it comes to community development expenditure financial addbacks.

It also appears the Baggies are disappointed the meticulous work under owners Bilkul, alongside the EFL, to bring down huge projected losses to make them in-line with regulations seems to have largely been overlooked.

The matter of community development expenditure, featuring in-kind donations to the charity partner, is the club’s main gripe and where they felt the strongest argument lays.

It is clear that within that disagreement is a breakdown in communication lines.

Their other relates to the interest recharge of the £28million loans from MSD Holdings prior to Shilen Patel’s takeover, with interest repayments of £5.2m.

Albion were of the opinion, as the result of a February 2024 share charge agreement, the MSD loan was moved to Bilkul.

The club provided evidence gained from a King’s Counsel to the hearing and club financial reporting panel (CFRP) to the above.

But the panel ruled the interest repayment remains with the club and therefore more than £5m losses were added to PSR calculations.

Evidence was provided by Albion chairman Patel, executive director Mark Miles, Foundation director Rob Lake and John Pelling, who came to the club on a short-term deal as a financial advisor last year with a fine reputation of guiding clubs, notably Stoke, through financial waters.

It provided little sway in the outcome.

The Baggies’ punishment could have been a one-point deduction, rather than two, if it was decided their co-operation had been “exceptional”. In this case it is difficult to see how more could have been done.

The punishment, mercifully, had no affect on Albion’s Championship status and you are left wondering on the convenience on the timing or the sanction.

Albion may have been expected to appeal out of ‘principle’ - but for practical time and financial reasons do not see fit.

Pertinent to Albion supporters, the club have no concern about their profit and sustainability position moving forward.

Several members of the Baggies hierarchy, including Miles in recent weeks, have confirmed the club’s PSR position is much clearer from this summer. Albion said in a statement: “The club is confident its PSR losses for the period ending 30 June 2026 will be well below the upper loss threshold.”

Despite their obvious unhappiness, they now they have an opportunity to draw a line under a messy, forgettable saga.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice