Birmingham City player ratings vs Peterborough: One 4/10 and several 5s in Vertu Trophy final horror show
Match report and player ratings from Birmingham City’s Vertu Trophy final defeat to Peterborough United at Wembley Stadium.
Birmingham City couldn’t follow up their League One title with a Vertu Trophy triumph as Harley Mills’ stunning free-kick and Hector Kyprianou’s clinical strike were enough to earn Peterborough United a surprise 2-0 victory over Blues at Wembley Stadium.
Birmingham’s’ big day out and first trip to Wembley since the League Cup win in 2011 failed to live up to expectations as Chris Davies’ side lacked vigour, direction and bite. It was meant to be a day of celebration and defiance but it was anything but as Mills and Kyprianou thrust daggers into Blues’ hearts to defend the Posh’s title.
Mills gave Peterborough a surprise lead in the 15th minute with an absolute stunner of a free-kick, curled in off the crossbar from 25 yards. It was an incredible moment for the Posh academy graduate, who couldn’t have struck the ball any better on his left foot, giving Blues goalkeeper Ryan Allsop no chance at full stretch. There were complaints that the foul from left-back Alex Cochrane on winger Kwame Poku was soft, but the replays showed clear contact.
Bluenoses were growing all the more frustrated as the first half wore on as Davies’ men failed to threaten the Peterborough box often enough. Blues had all of the possession but very little to show for it as they played in front of their opponents, patiently waiting for spaces that never really opened up. Keshi Anderson and Ethan Laird were the most direct but even they weren’t able to whip up any chances of note.
Peterborough piled on the misery for Blues as on the verge of half time Kyprianou doubled the Posh’s lead with a clinical strike into the roof of the net. Mills did what Birmingham’s attackers wouldn’t - making a daring dart down the wing - before delivering a low cross that deflected its way through to Kyprianou, who struck fiercely to convert from 15 yards. The Peterborough fans and manager Darren Ferguson went ballistic on the far side. The St Andrew’s faithful looked stunned.
Davies opted to make a half time change, substituting Willum Willumsson for Alfie May and moving Jay Stansfield out to the left flank. The tweak nearly made a rapid impact as Stansfield finally registered Blues’ first shot on target in the 52nd minute, cutting in and forcing a low stop from Jed Steer. Anderson squandered a big chance of his own a few minutes earlier as he struck miles high and wide, while Kieran Dowell wasted a free-kick by shooting straight at Steer.
Peterborough remained a threat on the counter-attack and went very close to scoring a third as Ricky-Jade Jones sprinted through but kicked Paik Seung-ho rather than the ball. Ryan Allsop then made a huge save on the follow-up, bravely diving low to deny Poku at point-blank range.
Stansfield thought he’d reduced the deficit for Blues in the 83rd minute as he pounced on the rebound from a Dowell shot and found the net from a few yards out, but the linesman’s flag was up for offside. It was the first time in half an hour that Birmingham had found a way in behind Peterborough’s robust low block.
The fourth official signalling 11 minutes of added time breathed an ounce of belief into the Birmingham fans and club legend Lukas Jutkiewicz, off the bench for a late cameo, so nearly gave the fans something to cheer as he forced a terrific stop from Steer. The hope fizzled out, however, as Peterborough were able to hold on.
Nobody can take away Birmingham’s immense League One title and promotion successes, but it’s a huge disappointment to not add the Vertu Trophy as the cherry on the cake. Blues must wait for their next silverware.
Birmingham player ratings vs Peterborough
Ryan Allsop - Couldn’t have done anything about Mills’ free-kick, nothing short of a wonder strike. Would’ve done well to get anything on Kyprianou’s goal, too. Made a great double save to deny Jones and Poku. Commanded his box well when required and was fairly accurate with his distribution. 6
Ethan Laird (off 64’) - One of Blues’ most direct players as he had a lot of joy down the right and won two or three free-kicks in decent areas. Also put in one massive sliding tackle to deny an almost certain goal from Odoh in the first half. Gave the ball away too many times, though, much to the frustration of the fans. 6
Christoph Klarer - Made a huge sliding tackle to block Jones from scoring in the 70th minute but otherwise didn’t have much of a say in the game. 6
Ben Davies (off 86’) - Didn’t do a great deal wrong, in fairness, but was still part of a defence which was slow in passing out from the back. 6
Alex Cochrane - Gave away the free-kick that led to Mills’ stunner as he fouled Poku in a dangerous area. Unable to make his usual impact with crosses. One dodgy touched jeered by the Posh fans at the end rather summed up his day. 5
Tomoki Iwata - Had a mixed game as he broke up the play well to help Blues dominate possession but failed to do enough with it. Not his best game. 6
Paik Seung-ho (off 73’) A similar game to Iwata as Paik saw a lot of the ball but couldn’t find enough incisive passes. Taken off with a knock midway through the second half, hopefully nothing serious. 6
Kieran Dowell - Probably his worst performance in a Blues shirt, and at the completely wrong time. Tasked with being a difference maker on the right but failed to penetrate the lines, gave the ball away more often than usual and wasted several free-kicks. Booked for a late lunge on Kyprianou. 4
Willum Willumsson (off at HT) - Set up the fourth minute chance for Stansfield with a great pass but was otherwise utterly ineffective behind the striker. Hooked at half time. 5
Keshi Anderson - Struggled to make his mark on the left flank as he was pocketed by Dornelly and was unable to make the desired impact. Moved over to the right in the second half and missed a great chance by skewing well over the bar. Set up the opportunity for Jutkiewicz, at least. 5
Jay Stansfield - Made some decent runs in behind but couldn’t score a dream Wembley goal. Fluffed a great chance to score just four minutes in, firing well wide. Had Blues’ first shot on target at the start of the second half but it didn’t trouble Steer. Denied a goal at the end by a narrow offside. 5
Alfie May (on at HT) Brought on for the second half and kept the Peterborough centre-halves busy. Couldn’t work any chances, though, and was booked for dissent after giving away a foul. 6
