Exclusive: Ex-Birmingham City defender discusses one big regret after West Ham transfer move

Jonathan Spector has spoken exclusively to BirminghamWorld about his decision to swap life at West Ham for a move to the West Midlands

After the disappointment of relegation in Alex McLeish’s final season at St Andrew’s and the coaches’ subsequent decision to controversially join Aston Villa, Chris Hughton was tasked with leading Birmingham City back into the Premier League while also spearheading the club’s first European campaign in 50 years.

Jonathan Spector explains decision to join Birmingham Cityplaceholder image
Jonathan Spector explains decision to join Birmingham City | Getty Images/ Canva

Hughton had to build a new team after a number of high profile losses, particularly in the heart of defence as the settled partnership of Roger Johnson and Scott Dann both departed - and he did this by bringing in Jonathan Spector from fellow relegated side West Ham United.

Spector, who mainly played in central defence, had been an ever-present at right-back for the USA at the 2010 World Cup, he’d racked up 100 appearances in the Premier League across spells at Manchester United, Charlton Athletic and West Ham - and he’d notably followed in the footsteps of names like Paul Scholes and Ryan Giggs by winning the Jimmy Murphy Young Player of the Year as a youngster at Old Trafford.

West Ham had wanted to keep him on board despite finishing bottom but Spector told BirminghamWorld in an exclusive interview that he was convinced to relocate to the West Midlands when he heard Hughton would be the manager.

Jonathan Spector explains decision to join Birmingham City

Speaking to BirminghamWorld, Spector said: “Going back, I really enjoyed my time at the club. You know, having been there for five and a half seasons, the goal for me was always to get the club promoted. Part of the calculus for me was that we'd just been relegated with West Ham when I was there, and Birmingham got relegated that same season. West Ham, at the time, didn't have a manager.

“I had the opportunity to stay, but I just didn't know who the manager was going to be, and I knew who it was going to be at Birmingham and I really liked him; Chris Hughton. I heard nothing but great things about him, had a conversation with him, and was really on board with his idea, his philosophy.”

Hughton, who has since ventured into international football, was fairly new to management at that stage of his career, but he’d already shown great Championship pedigree by spearheading the Magpies to a league title and promotion with a staggering 102 points, while avoiding a single home defeat.

However, with the added demands of European football and as problems at ownership level slowly crept in behind the scenes, Blues finished fourth missing out on promotion via the play-off semi-finals to Blackpool as Spector’s former club eventually won promotion at Wembley.

“In hindsight we, Birmingham, ended up losing in the playoffs, and West Ham won the playoffs, so maybe the wrong choice! But at the time, that was the decision I made.”

Spector reflects fondly on his time at Birmingham City

Overall, Spector racked up 179 appearances for the Blues, all while playing in Europe for the first and only time while also helping the club to navigate their way through some difficult fights to avoid relegation.

“So, I look back on it in a couple different ways,” added Spector. “One, disappointed that I didn't get the chance to achieve promotion - that was my goal in going there, so I was certainly disappointed with that. But I really enjoyed the club, the fans, the five-and-a-half years that I had there.

“Also, when I chose to come back to the MLS in the middle of the season, it was for family reasons. And the club couldn't have been better in terms of how they handled it. And of course, I built a rapport with some of the people there but nonetheless they were very understanding of my personal circumstances and situation, and they were brilliant to me. So, nothing but good things to say about the club. Just disappointed I never managed to get the club promoted back to the Premier League.”

Birmingham haven’t qualified for the Championship play-offs since Spector’s time at the club. However, they are optimistic about their chances of ending that season under Chris Davies, with the backing of the club’s US based owners.

Blues’ longest run without being in the top flight (which includes the Premier League era and the old First Division) was 16 seasons, between 1986 and 2002. That feat will be equalled if they fail to win promotion this term.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice