Birmingham City player ratings vs Rotherham United: ‘Shocking performance’ as no outfield player scores more than 5

Player ratings from the New York Stadium.

Birmingham City put in a shocking performance to lose 2-0 at Rotherham United on Saturday afternoon.

Two goals from Richard Wood, one in either half, were enough to hand the home side all three points in a game Blues will want to quickly, quickly forget.

Here’s how BirminghamWorld rated the players performances - and they don’t make for pretty reading.

John Ruddy of Birmingham City saves a penalty from Dan Barlaser of Rotherham United during the Sky Bet Championship between Rotherham United and Birmingham Cityplaceholder image
John Ruddy of Birmingham City saves a penalty from Dan Barlaser of Rotherham United during the Sky Bet Championship between Rotherham United and Birmingham City | Getty Images

John Ruddy - 7*

Made a couple of good saves on the afternoon and stopped a penalty. Can’t really ask for much more from your keeper. MOTM - not that he had much competition.

Josh Williams - 5

Tried incredibly hard. Granted, the quality wasn’t there at times but his workrate was a cut above a lot of his teammates.

Marc Roberts - 3

Really bad afternoon compounded by bringing a Rotherham man down in the box.

Dion Sanderson - 5

Best of the back three.

Auston Trusty - 4

Was lucky to not concede a penalty of his own in the first-half when he chopped down Ogbene. Got away with one.

Maxime Colin - 5

Replaced at half-time with an injury.

Juninho Bacuna - 5

Blues’ star-man a lot of the time but was pretty non-existent today.

Jordan James - 4

Bullied in the middle of the park all day.

 George Hall of Birmingham City passes the ball during the Sky Bet Championship between Rotherham United and Birmingham Cityplaceholder image
George Hall of Birmingham City passes the ball during the Sky Bet Championship between Rotherham United and Birmingham City | Getty Images

George Hall - 5

Not a bad performance but not a great one either. Hard to expect much from someone with so few senior appearances on his belt.

Troy Deeney - 4

Could have had a goal had Hogan squared an opportunity at the beginning of the second-half but away fro that, never looked threatening.

Scott Hogan - 3

Birmingham’s opportunities were extremely few and far between and he had the best by a country mile. Fired a one-on-one straight at the Rotherham keeper. Not good enough.

Subs

Jordan Graham - 5

Steady when he came on after the break going forward but struggled defensively.

Sam Cosgrove - 5

Actually thought he did OK when he came on. Better than his two strike partners that started.

Gary Gardner - 5

Didn’t do anything of note really but at least Blues seemed to gain a little bit of control in the middle following his introduction.

Ryan Stirk - 5

A lot to ask of a young player to change a game like this. Didn’t particularly notice him when brought on.

Jobe Bellingham - N/A

Brought on with less than 10 to go.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice