Aston Villa player ratings vs Everton: two 'dreadful' 4s after Thierno Barry exploits Villa blunders
Premier League result, player ratings and report after Aston Villa 0-1 Everton.
Thierno Barry scored the winner as Everton abruptly ended Aston Villa’s remarkable 11-game home winning streak, claiming a surprise 1-0 victory at Villa Park.


Unai Emery’s side were stunned as Barry exploited blunders from both Emiliano Martinez and Pau Torres to delicately convert the only goal of the game. Villa missed a host of chances and should have left with a goal of their own at the very least, but Everton, who struck the woodwork just 11 seconds in and were disallowed a goal from Jake O’Brien for a controversial offside, were good value for the three points.
Barry’s winner was a clinical one as the striker dinked over Martinez, who had spilled an effort from Dwight McNeil after Pau Torres gave away the ball cheaply on the edge of his own area. Emery was despondent on the touchline, utterly speechless that his side could let two such simple errors creep in at such a pivotal moment.
Morgan Rogers was the most threatening player for the hosts as he saw two terrific efforts saved by Jordan Pickford, while another was stopped by a last-ditch block from O’Brien. Youri Tielemans was a creative outlet, too, but Villa were otherwise well off their usual pace.
To make matters worse amid an already ongoing injury crisis, captain John McGinn was forced off just 17 minutes into the game after going down with what appeared to be an innocuous knee problem. Emery will have everything crossed that it’s nothing serious, just a week after Boubacar Kamara suffered a similar blow.
Goalkeeper and defence ratings
Emiliano Martinez: Returned from his calf injury with a huge error as he spilled McNeil’s shot, allowing Barry to score. Martinez made a good save from Mykolenko in the first half but that won’t be remembered. His dreadful error will. 4
Matty Cash: Dealt with Grealish fairly well, reading the former Villan’s jinks in and out for the most part and only giving away a couple of fouls. Cash swung in a few good crosses, including for Tielemans’ header just wide. 6
Ezri Konsa: Sprinted back to try and acrobatically clear off the line for Barry’s goal but couldn’t quite do enough. Konsa made some important defensive interventions to prevent Everton scoring more, but his passing out from the back was far too laboured. 6
Pau Torres: The other at fault for Barry’s goal, Pau gave the ball away to McNeil in the immediate build-up with a terrible first touch. Pau got away with a similar error in the first half, albeit a little further away from his goal on that occasion. His passing had mixed success. 4
Ian Maatsen (off 73’): Struggled to play out of trouble on several occasions and wasn’t physical enough in his duels. 5
Midfield and attack ratings
Lamare Bogarde (off 73’): Showed his frailties as he gave away possession cheaply on several occasions, allowing Everton to break. Booked for a late challenge through the back of Grealish. 5
Youri Tielemans: Villa’s best player on a drab afternoon, Tielemans threaded the ball through the eye of a needle to create a super chance for Guessand and then crossed brilliantly to find the Ivorian for a header onto the bar. Tielemans missed a good chance of his own, though, as he headed wide in the second half. 7*
Emiliano Buendia: Linked up the play well and used his flair to create space on the half turn. Got both McNeil and Garner booked as he dribbled away from the Everton pair. Took too long to release the ball for Rogers for an early chance, mind. 7
John McGinn (off 17’): Forced off just over a quarter of an hour into the game after going down with what looked like a knee injury. Looked in good shape before that unfortunate moment. 6
Morgan Rogers: Wasn’t able to light up Villa Park on his 100th appearance for the club but looked Villa’s most likely player to score. Rogers was denied by a last-ditch block and a Pickford save in the first half. He then saw a great curler stopped by Pickford in the second period. Rogers had a host of penalty shouts turned down by referee Tony Harrington. 6
Ollie Watkins: Freed up to start following the sale of Donyell Malen to Roma, Watkins wasn’t able to carry on his fine recent form. The England international’s hold-up play was relatively poor in front of the onlooking Thomas Tuchel. 5
Substitutes ratings
Evann Guessand (on 17’): Missed a huge chance in the first half as he skewed his shot straight at the goalkeeper. Guessand hit the bar with a looping header just before the break. The Ivorian then struggled to make inroads when moved to the flank. 5
George Hemmings (on 73’): A solid and mature cameo from the youngster, albeit in unideal circumstances. 7
Lucas Digne (on 73’): Failed to make the desired impact and lacked accuracy with his deliveries into the box. 5
