Forget Thiago: Aston Villa must swerve £50m transfer gamble and sign Bundesliga gem instead

Aston Villa should keep their transfer options open ahead of the January transfer window

Aston Villa are reportedly aiming to bolster their attack in the January transfer window amidst a lack of striking options for Unai Emery’s side.

Aston Villa are set to target a new striker in January.placeholder image
Aston Villa are set to target a new striker in January. | Getty Images

The Villans are in outstanding form, putting together several victories in the league to rise into the Champions League conversation as we enter December. Victory was secured in last weekend’s West Midlands derby as Boubacar Kamara struck the only goal of the game from the edge of the box.

But a problem remains for Emery’s men, in the fact that Ollie Watkins continues to struggle badly in front of goal and the Spaniard has few alternatives to the England international. Watkins has had goal-scoring issues this term and while Donyell Malen has stepped up when called upon, the Dutchman, Morgan Rogers and Emiliano Buendia have all been tasked with sharing a handful of goals each in the Premier League.

While the ability shown by the Villa Park outfit to share the goals around the side has been admirable, another striking option may be paramount in January if their Champions League challenge is to be a sustained one.

Aston Villa should avoid expensive move for Igor Thiago

Aston Villa have been linked with Brentford striker Igor Thiago ahead of the transfer window, and are reportedly prepared to pay £50 million for the Brazilian following his outstanding start to the Premier League season.

Thiago has already hit double figures this season but, despite this, to pay a fee of at least £50m, minimum – possibly even more – for a player who has played regularly at the highest level in England for just half a season would be a major risk. Villa have recently been teetering on the edge of breaking financial rules as it is, and such an expensive signing could prove costly if it were to go wrong.

Cheaper and potentially equally effective options lie elsewhere on the market, and Villa would be smart to take a look at Bundesliga marksman Jonathan Burkardt as an alternative.

Bundesiga ace Burkardt could prove masterstroke Emery signing

The 25-year-old Germany international only joined Eintracht Frankfurt in July in a €21m (£18.5m) deal, after 11 years at fellow Bundesliga outfit Mainz 05 culminated in Burkardt scoring 18 league goals last season. Interestingly, this is more than both Hugo Ekitike and Benjamin Sesko managed in the Bundesliga last term, before the two strikers sealed big-money moves to the Premier League.

Burkardt has already scored 10 times for his new club in just 17 games and could attract interest in 2026. Frankfurt would be reluctant to let their new star marksman depart so soon, but the Champions League outfit are famously astute at replacing star strikers and will be confident in their ability to do so once again. His current market value is €35m according to Transfermarkt, while the player is currently set to be out injured until January following a recent calf issue.

Even if Frankfurt insist on doubling their profits on the striker, his transfer fee would still be significantly lower than that of Thiago. While buying from abroad always constitutes a higher risk, it allows for the opportunity to secure a gem of a signing for a comparatively reasonable price. There is no doubt that Burkardt possesses the ability to be prolific in England, and his signing could prove to be a difference-maker as Villa look to take the goal-scoring burden off Watkins and go all the way on multiple fronts come the end of the season.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice