Aston Villa player ratings vs Crystal Palace: three contentious 8s & two 5s awarded after frustrating 0-0 draw

Premier League result, player ratings and report after Crystal Palace 0-0 Aston Villa.

Aston Villa were unable to end their Crystal Palace hoodoo as the Champions League-chasing Villans were held to a 0-0 draw at Selhurst Park on Wednesday evening.

Unai Emery’s side had several opportunities to win the game and they perhaps should have done, made to rue missed chances on a night several rivals near the top of the table dropped points.

The in-form Ollie Watkins, regularly set up by fellow England international Morgan Rogers, was unable to find a way through for the visitors as he missed three big chances.

Palace, inspired by new signing Brennan Johnson, had several decent opportunities of their own but were denied by Villa goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez – and his half-time replacement, Marco Bizot.

Much of the action was in the second period as there was just one shot on target apiece in the first 45 minutes. It became more and more open approaching the final whistle, but Villa, despite upping the ante late on, dropped points in the capital.

Emery was apoplectic at full-time, bubbling over in a rare protest at referee Andy Madley. It was unclear what the Villa boss was so furious about, perhaps at his team’s inability to convert their chances, but there was no doubting his displeasure.

Here’s how the Villa players rated at Selhurst Park.

Goalkeeper and defence ratings

Emiliano Martinez (off 46’): Made a good stop from Johnson midway through the first half and was hardly fazed by Palace’s high press. Substituted at the break, most likely due to his ongoing back issue. 6

Matty Cash: Got into advanced areas plenty and often made late runs into the area. Whipped in some terrific crosses, causing all sorts of problems for the Palace defence. Rarely gave Mitchell or Pino a sniff on his side. 8*

Ezri Konsa: Had plenty of Palace crosses to deal with and dealt with them effectively. Konsa marshalled the back four strongly, as per usual. 7

Victor Lindelof: Had a mixed game as he progressed well in possession but lacked a little defensively, standing off Pino and Johnson for their shots on target. 6

Lucas Digne (off 73’): Kept Johnson and Devenny relatively quiet, making his fair share of tackles and recoveries. Provided good depth down the left but lacked accuracy with his crossing. 7

Midfield and attack ratings

Boubacar Kamara: Risked it all with a last-ditch sliding challenge on Mitchell and timed it perfectly, stopping the Palace left-back from scoring from close range. Looked composed on the ball for the most part, too. 7

Youri Tielemans: Fought hard to break up the play as often as possible but wasn’t as creative as we’ve seen in recent weeks. Tielemans played the odd decent pass into the final third but didn’t create any chances of note. 7

John McGinn (off 73’): Struggled to carry over any momentum from his brace against Forest. Turned away from challenges well but lacked with his end product, often inaccurate with his final passes. Didn’t win any of his ground duels. 5

Morgan Rogers: Teed up Watkins for two decent chances in the first half and was regularly a danger when weaving in and out of Palace’s defenders. Missed a big chance late on, skewing just over the bar. 6

Jadon Sancho (off 65’): Unable to make much of an impact on his 100th Premier League appearance as he was pocketed by Guehi and Mitchell. 5

Ollie Watkins: Had Villa’s three best chances and missed them all, but two of the three attempts were decent. The first was a cheeky dink just about saved, the second blocked after an unnecessary delay and the third off the post with his head. On another day, Watkins could have had a brace. He got in all the right positions. 7

Substitutes ratings

Marco Bizot (on 46’): Stepped in for Martinez unexpectedly and stood up to the task, making a string of saves to deny Pino (twice) and Johnson. 8

Emiliano Buendia (on 65’): Didn’t influence the game as much as Emery would have hoped. 6

Ian Maatsen & Donyell Malen (on 73’), Lamare Bogarde (on 82’): Not much to report for the trio, who all came on with fewer than 20 minutes to go. 6

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice