Aston Villa player ratings vs Newcastle: two dazzling 9/10s as Unai Emery’s men end St. James’ Park hoodoo

Premier League result, player ratings and report after Newcastle United 0-2 Aston Villa.

Aston Villa finally ended their St. James’ Park hoodoo with a hard-fought 2-0 victory away at Newcastle United, courtesy of an Emiliano Buendia stunner and a late Ollie Watkins header.

Emiliano Buendia and Ollie Watkins scored the goals as Aston Villa beat Newcastle United 2-0 at St. James' Park.placeholder image
Emiliano Buendia and Ollie Watkins scored the goals as Aston Villa beat Newcastle United 2-0 at St. James' Park. | Getty Images

The Villans hadn’t won in any of their last 17 visits to Newcastle, dating back to 2005, however Unai Emery’s side put on a tremendous display to claim all three points and temporarily move to within four of Premier League leaders Arsenal.

Buendia roared the away end into life with a barnstorming strike 19 minutes in, giving Pope absolutely no chance. The Argentine’s rocket, from no fewer than 25 yards, dipped and swerved wickedly into the far corner for his seventh goal of the season.

The Magpies piled on the pressure in the second period but Watkins then made sure of the points, nodding in from a teasing Lucas Digne cross to double Villa’s advantage on 88 minutes.

Emiliano Martinez, back in the team following a calf injury, deserves plenty of credit for an excellent response to recent critics. The World Cup winner made a pivotal stop from Sandro Tonali early on and was at full stretch to deny Lewis Miley a close-range header before the interval.

The only real downer on the day for Villa was yet another midfield injury concern, as Youri Tielemans was forced off with a quarter of an hour to go. The Belgium international twisted his ankle under a challenge from Miley. Emery will be praying his number eight hasn’t sustained any serious damage.

Goalkeeper and defence ratings

Here’s how the Villa players rated on Tyneside.

Emiliano Martinez: Back in the team following his injury and shone on his 200th Premier League appearance. Martinez denied Tonali a rapid opener with a strong save with his feet in the opening 90 seconds. He also made a magnificent stop from a Miley header before half time and dominated his area, making lots of important claims. 9

Matty Cash: Continued his fine form with a comfortable display. Cash kept Gordon at bay for the most part and provided good width down the right. 7

Ezri Konsa: Marshalled the back four superbly. Konsa, who should be an easy pick for Thomas Tuchel’s World Cup squad, proved why with a dominant display. 8

Pau Torres (off 75’): Positioned himself well to deal with a host of Trippier and Barnes crosses. Much improved from the rather questionable performance against Everton. 7

Ian Maatsen: Still ahead of Digne in the pecking order, Maatsen really enjoyed his duel with Harvey Barnes. The Dutchman pocketed Newcastle’s number 11, though he was booked for tugging back Elanga in stoppage time. 8

Midfield and attack ratings

Amadou Onana (off 89’): Battled hard throughout and took a painful stamp from Joelinton in the first half. Emery was glad to see Onana continue after he received the magic spray, as his physicality in midfield was important. 8

Youri Tielemans (off 74’): Dictated the tempo of the game for large stretches in the first half and was incisive with his passing through the Newcastle press. Tielemans did go off late on with an ankle injury, though, so that a real concern. 8

Emiliano Buendia (off 75’): The Argentine, who scored a wonderful goal to break the deadlock, is brimming with confidence. Buendia was a constant threat on the transition, linking up well with Rogers and having two shots saved either side of his goal. He also worked hard to defend in the second half. 9*

Morgan Rogers: Assisted Buendia’s goal with a tidy pass inside. Deserved it as he linked up well with Villa’s number 10 all game long and he played a clever outside-of-the-boot through ball to Watkins before the break. Rogers also did his defensive duties brilliantly, chopping in to make plenty of recoveries. 8

Jadon Sancho (off 59’): Had a lively start and created a great chance for Watkins early on, playing through the eye of a needle. Quietened down a little but can still be proud of his efforts. 7

Ollie Watkins: Headed in Villa’s vital second goal, through the legs of Pope. Saw an early shot on target saved, but it was a decent effort. Just like Rogers, Watkins was aware enough to make defensive contributions in advanced areas. 8

Substitutes ratings

Leon Bailey (on 59’): Back after his loan recall from Roma, Bailey didn’t do much going forward but he worked hard to support Cash in the defensive third. 7

Lucas Digne (on 75’): Notched the assist for Watkins’ goal with a terrific cross. 7

Other subs: Lamare Bogarde (on 74’), Tyrone Mings (on 75’), Victor Lindelof (89’).

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice