Concerns raised as US dog trainer’s sold-out Birmingham Workshop faces RSPCA backlash over shock collar use
A dog trainer has announced a workshop in Birmingham in January, prompting concerns from the RSPCA about animal welfare.
US-based Ivan Balabanov is holding a workshop in Birmingham from 17 to 19 January 2025.


The venue has yet to be announced, though social media posts state that the workshop is sold out. The animal welfare organisation said the trainer uses shock collars.
Shock collars are currently legal in the UK, although the Government did announce a ban on the use of the collars on dogs and cats in England, but the legislation has yet to be passed.
The RSPCA has said it has written to Mr Balabanov raising concerns about this type of training method and has offered to meet him, but is yet to receive a response.While still legal to use in England, using shock collars on dogs and cats is already illegal in neighbouring Wales.
What are shock collars?
Electric shock collars are used by some to train dogs by applying a shock to the dog’s neck when displaying unwanted behaviour. To reduce the unwanted behaviour, the shock needs to be strong enough for a dog to feel and to be of sufficient magnitude for them to be fearful of feeling that shock again.
But the RSPCA said research has shown that this type of training causes pain and the use of such devices can actually risk causing further problems.
Dr Samantha Gaines, dog welfare expert at the RSPCA, said: “Shock collars are unnecessary and cruel. It concerns us that there are workshops taking place in the UK which promote training techniques that can cause pain and distress and may actually worsen behavioural problems.
“We have concerns about the equipment Mr Balabanov uses, including shock and prong collars and we’re urging people to take a stand with us on this.”


The use of these collars also requires the dog to associate being shocked with their unwanted behaviour. Creating fear in this way risks numerous negative consequences for the dog and owner.
Dogs may associate the shock with other things in their environment, such as other dogs or people, and learn to avoid or be aggressive towards these.
Dr Gaines added: “It is neither necessary nor acceptable to use these collars. We promote and recommend reward-based training techniques that dogs like or enjoy and have been shown to be very effective in achieving long-term change in behaviour without compromising dog welfare.
“There is a wealth of evidence from around the world which supports the effectiveness of positive training methods, which is now widely used by many across the world, including not only pet dog trainers but also the military and assistance dogs organisations which require dogs to be trained to an extremely high standard.”
In January this year, the UK Government announced a ban on the use of shock collars on dogs and cats in England, with a proposed date for the new law in February.
However, Parliament didn’t get time to debate it before July’s General Election - meaning the new legislation didn’t come into effect .The use of shock collars on dogs and cats is already illegal in Wales.
RSPCA has written to trainer but the organisation said it had no response.
