I experienced fine Italian cuisine with an autumn twist at San Carlo’s original Birmingham restaurant

Autumn flavours take centre stage at San Carlo Birmingham

San Carlo, which is renowned for its exquisite Italian food, formally marked the festive season with its autumn/winter menu, and what a wonderful three-course dining experience it was.

The idea that pasta and pumpkin may work well together, and even go hand-in-hand with one another was a combination I never thought needed in my life until I tried the Cartellate Zucca e Tartufo.

San Carlo is located on Temple Street in Birmingham City Centreplaceholder image
San Carlo is located on Temple Street in Birmingham City Centre | Mimi Ibrahim

So if you’re looking for a spot to ring in the festive season, then you definitely cannot go wrong with this Birmingham staple spot.

Despite the fact that San Carlo has become a massive global brand.

The restaurant still maintains its Birmingham roots, as San Carlo first opened its first restaurant right here in Birmingham back in 1992.

The restaurant’s staff and general hospitality also made the experience that much more wonderful and special.

So when I first arrived here at the heart of Birmingham city centre on Temple Street, I was excited to be able to indulge in the new menu and before I arrived at the restaurant I perused the menu.

As expected there were the firm favourites like pasta and gelato and I made sure not to get myself into the bread as I readily awaited for the meals to arrive.

I made sure not to get too carried away on the bread as the menu was full of lots of classic flavours with an autumnal twist. I must admit that the focaccia tasted chewy and slightly salty though it had the moisture through the olive.

I sipped on a delightfully fruity mocktail called Terra that was simply too good not to try.

Its sweet and fruity flavour was a refreshing cool drink in between the various dishes that I tried.

Terraplaceholder image
Terra | Mimi Ibrahim

For the starters there were two standouts for me which were the Heritage Tomato Salad that had a sweet tanginess flavour to the meal.

Heritage Tomato Saladplaceholder image
Heritage Tomato Salad | Mimi Ibrahim

Alongside the Polenta Fritta & Crab which was fried polenta and crab, which was surprisingly very easy to nibble one, and before I knew it I finished all three that were on my plate.

 Polenta Fritta & Crabplaceholder image
Polenta Fritta & Crab | Mimi Ibrahim

The main for me was the highlight of the evening.

The Cartellate Zucca e Tartufo was amazingly flavourful. I particularly liked the taste of the pumpkin, I’ve never thought pasta and pumpkin complimented each other really well. And I cannot stop thinking about this combination. The pumpkin added a depth and a sweetness of flavour that immediately took my fancy. It was a familiar warm feeling that complimented the creamy nature of the pasta in a way that I hadn’t experienced before.

Cartellate Zucca e Tartufoplaceholder image
Cartellate Zucca e Tartufo | Mimi Ibrahim

I was so full, but I managed to find room in my stomach, to indulge in dessert, and there were two sweet treats that I was impressed by.

The first was the nutty flavour of the Torta Pistacchio, known as pistachio cake and also the Mantecato alla Nocciola which was a soft hazelnut ice cream that included crushed Ferro Rocher and chocolate sauce.

The dessert was extremely decadent and I really appreciated watching the server prepare the ice-cream in a precise and joyful fashion.

The server preparing dessertplaceholder image
The server preparing dessert | Mimi Ibrahim

All in all, the autumn/winter menu that’s available in season is a must-try and there’s no better San Carlo to try than the original one that’s right here in Brum!

San Carlo is located at 4 Temple St, Birmingham B2 5B.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice