Film reviews: Dwayne Johnson and Emily Blunt go toe to toe in fight drama
Wrestler turned actor The Rock proves he’s the real deal as a lord of the ring and screen
Films by Graham Young
THE SMASHING MACHINE (15, 123 mins) ****
Dwayne Johnson has always had star quality on the silver screen – and the physique to match.
For all of his box office hits, though, some of his films, like Tooth Fairy (2010), have been risible if well-intentioned fodder for families.
Finally, he's now got the vehicle to prove that he’s a fine actor thanks to this slow-burn dramatisation of the real-life birth of mixed martial arts fighting towards the dawn of the new millennium.
Based on a 2002 documentary called The Smashing Machine: The Life and Times of Extreme Fighter Mark Kerr, the film is light years away from going through the gears of excitement like a typical action-led movie.
With his personal demons just one false move away, talk-heavy scenes with Dawn (Emily Blunt) are much more akin to Sam Mendes’ Revolutionary Road (2008) than the later Rocky sequels.
Kerr’s fight sequences showcasing the emerging sport won’t leave viewers feeling smashed up – they lack edge-of-seat momentum and the violence is often hidden by the ring’s ropes, too.
Instead, it's the personal journey undertaken in his head by amateur wrestler turned MMA / UFC fighter Kerr (Johnson) that counts, not the depiction of a violent ‘sport’ that I, for one, will never warm to compared with traditional boxing.
With two of the key characters having such similar names (Mark Kerr and Mark Coleman), there’s an unintentional if temporary disconnect when either character is referred to by either name.
Whether sporting a full head of hair or not, Johnson’s immersion in his (impressively physically bulked-up) role makes him almost unrecognisable even from his usual large self.
Rarely will an actor ever have had to work so hard to challenge his silver screen dream, not least because the now 53-year-old Johnson is on the wrong side of his half-century for such a physical part.
London-born Blunt, fast becoming a queen of Hollywood, is an authentic foil for Johnson, too – her character willing to risk all with the kind of wild lifestyle that would signal the end for him.
Dawn gives as good as she gets when her relationship with Kerr edges towards the kind of domestic violence which - intentionally or otherwise - makes you think of a certain South African athlete nicknamed the Blade Runner. But do we ever know enough about either lead character to truly care about their fates?
Working without brother Benny after they both made Adam Sandler’s Uncut Gems (2019), writer-director Bennie Safdie has also edited the film’s different shooting formats (including 16mm).
More significantly, it’s great that Hollywood has finally trusted Johnson with an ‘adult’ role, mirroring the natural empathy that Blunt herself clearly developed by working with the imposing star on Jungle Cruise (2021).
Just like post-Rambo muscle mountain Sylvester Stallone proved his mettle as a deaf sheriff in James Mangold’s Cop Land (1997), this is Johnson’s calling-card movie.
But whereas Stallone ended up having to resort back to type with The Expendables etc, one hopes The Rock will get the chance to build on his newly-found core strength again sooner rather than later – because Father Time decrees that his massive muscles won’t always be able to do the heavy lifting.
HIM (18, 96 mins) **
Films about American Football generally leave me nonplussed at the best of times, but even though this has been produced by Jordan Peele (Get Out) and blends horror with sport to give fans of either genre something new to feast on, the over-the-top finale left my blood boiling rather than chilled for the right reasons.
Taught by his father to appreciate the game as a child plonked in front of the telly, Cam (Tyriq Withers) later becomes the protege of ageing quarterback Isaiah White (Marlon Wayans).
Rather like Demi Moore’s far superior The Substance, director Justin Tipping strives for style first and foremost here.
The plot about how masculinity might create a monster is clearly of worthy intent when power and fame are two of the driving forces, but the film soon becomes convoluted and laboured before giving way way to such extremely graphic violence it desensitises the whole project.
Unlike The Smashing Machine, Him never even borders on smashing.
URCHIN (15, 99 mins) ***
There’s a much better film than Him hiding inside of Urchin given that its insights into a real-life crisis feel relevant.
Actor Stephen Dillane’s son Frank Dillane (who was a young Tom Riddle in Harry Potter) plays Mike, a scruffy-haired homeless man who goes from being typically ignored whilst begging for change in the street to becoming a kitchen cook with the tools of the job.
Along the way, he’s sent to prison – but will he have learned the error of his ways. Can others who try to help – friends, mentors and counsellors – succeed and/or trust him?
Urchin is a mirror to what is happening in our cities today and inevitably asks far more questions than it can answer.
Actor and writer-director Harris Dickinson (soon to play John Lennon across four Beatles movies) is commendably content to let his camera do much of the talking.
But some of the plot devices are unconvincing and the 99-minute running time is excessive despite our willingness for Mike to survive and thrive.
Birmingham’s own writer-director Steve Rainbow moved me more with the heartfelt NFA (No Fixed Abode) back in 2012 – and in just 81 mins, too.
+ Graham Young is a former UK Regional Film Journalist of the Year and three-time runner-up.
CREDITS
The Smashing Machine / Entertainment Film Distributors
Him / Universal
Urchin / Picturehouse Entertainment