Film reviews: Avatar 3? James Cameron should have made his third Terminator movie instead…

placeholder image

Sci-fi spectacular Avatar’s second sequel battles its own complexities and extravagant running time.

Films by Graham Young

AVATAR: FIRE AND ASH (12A, 197 mins) ***

OSCAR-winning director James Cameron is not a man who does things by halves as he proved with the sheer scale of Titanic (1998).

Avatar: Fire & Ash is the first time he’s delivered a third main course from the same fillet, with fourth and fifth offerings still to come on December 21, 2029 and then December 19, 2031.

So that’s plenty of time for his increasingly special performance capture effects to make the previous ones look, er, rather dated – never mind that it’s all taking so long that editor John Refoua (2023) and producer Jon Landau (2024) have already died en route.

The Avatar saga began brilliantly in 2009 when we first met the paraplegic Jake Sully (Sam Worthington). With the earth’s resources depleted, the battle was on to mine an Earth-sized moon called Pandora. Jake’s avatar cleverly enabled him to romantically interact with the Na’vi, the term for the indigenous humanoid inhabitants – whose own existence now remains under threat.

A sequel Avatar: The Way of Water (2022) moved the story on by 16 years, with Cameron’s deeply-personal love of diving translating to Jake trying to keep his family safe in Pandora’s watery regions.

Set a year later in 2171, Fire and Ash sees more conflict between the Na’vi and the Resources Development Administration (RDA) as well as serving to introduce the tough ‘Ash People’ who happen to live near volcanoes.

So now we literally have fire and ash as well as even more fantastical squid and whale-like creatures – not forgetting, of course, that chance to go airborne again on the back of flying dragons.

Alas! The bad news for Cameron’s cinematographer Russell Carpenter (True Lies) is that 16 years of incredible Avatar production values later, birds in our own natural world still have the superior, more natural technique and you can bet that will still be the case in 2031.

That well-worn element alone is like blending How to Train Your Dragon with Harry Potter’s Quidditch wizards.

The continued development of Avatar-specific language, time and place is, of course, another cinematic reminder of how former Birmingham resident JRR Tolkien did much the same thing with The Lord of the Rings, having himself been fascinated by dragons as child like so many generations before him.

Fire and Ash has some fabulous visuals and battle scenes, but is not strong on delivering a beginning, middle and end, nor is any of the dialogue especially memorable. Seeing the initial two films first won’t necessarily make part three any more comprehensible either.

One of the ‘bladed weapon’ scenes in particular is doubly regrettable given the deadly nature of knife crime in our own world and that the film has nothing stronger than a 12A certificate.

Many of Avatar’s blue-faced characters are so interchangeable, just keeping up with who’s who is just one of the film’s many challenges – a feeling that composer Simon Franglen would surely acknowledge given that his score struggles to knit the film’s various themes together.

Still, for Cameron that might mean some viewers take more sittings despite the fact that the mammoth 197-minute running time and the film's scarcely-believable artificial scale makes generating a consistent head of steam virtually impossible.

I first saw Fire and Ash on a basic 2D screen in the hope that building up to a repeat viewing on a more spectacular IMAX 3D will provide added value as well as deepening knowledge of all of the things viewers inevitably miss first time around.

But, if truth be told, there is one film that the now 71-year-old Cameron should have been making by now – and that’s Terminator 2029.

We are literally just three years short of the world that Cameron perceptively envisaged during the beginning of his original Terminator film back in 1984.

Comparatively low budget and with a star better known for his Mr Universe muscles than his acting (Arnold Schwarzenegger), the film raised the bar for accessible sci-fi fantasy, a feat cemented with its sequel Terminator 2 in 1991.

Foolishly, perhaps, Cameron left the Terminator franchise for others while he turned to True Lies and then began to set his sights on Titanic and then Avatar.

The three later Terminator films – Salvation, 2009; Genisys, 2015 and Dark Fate, 2019 – were never as good as the ones he directed.

But the world is now increasingly being torn apart by global conflicts, energy crises and the politically-charged world of ‘global warming’ theories.

With the race towards full AI gaining traction alongside remote-controlled drone warfare and even the emergence of Chinese robots which can run, now was surely the time for Cameron the physicist to be making a third Terminator film reflecting on his now 40-year-old vision for life on Earth in 2029 by way of another leap into an increasingly uncertain future.

Cameron recently said he feared for the future of cinema. Making films that go 17 minutes over three hours probably won’t help to save it no matter that the inflated box office figures say – because as many people again will not find the time.

Fire and Ash is only his third movie this century (and just his sixth since 1990). Cameron’s closest rival for scale and spectacle, Britain’s own Christopher Nolan, has made 11 films since 2000 with Matt Damon up next in his twelfth movie, The Odyssey, out on July 17, 2026.

Now that’s the future…

Reviewing films in Birmingham since 1989, Graham Young is a former UK Regional Film Journalist of the Year and three-time runner-up

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice